Borges: Garden of Forking Paths & The Form of the Sword
Although I’m not a fan of war literature, Borges kept me
interested with the plot twists before the end of each story.
I read Garden of Forking Paths first. I will admit I was a
little bored while reading the first few pages. But he made some interesting
points that are obvious but have you star-struck when you realize them. I had
an “oh sh*t” moment when he wrote, “Then I reflected that all
things happen, happen to one, precisely now. Century follows century, and
things happen only in the present.” Idk, that was just interesting to me. It
reminds to focus on the present and not dwell in the past or worry too much
about the future. I like the fact the narrator isn’t acting on patriotism but
is instead working to show his intelligence and ultimately his worth as an
Asian man to the German military. The ending was fascinating solely because the manner
he revealed the secret he was sitting on was clever!! There were a number of
suspenseful moments in the story: when the narrator emptied out his pockets to
obtain his pistol, when Captain Madden was spotted on the platform, when Madden
was walking up the path to Albert’s house, etc. In a sense, these all contribute to the
mystery in the story. The mystery also lies in the significance of the book or
the labyrinth the narrator’s ancestor never finished.
I liked The Form of the Sword a little more (not just
because it was shorter). I thought the whole Garden of the Forking Paths
mystery was kind of distracting from the good stuff—the reason Albert had to die.
The Form of the Sword ended with a great plot twist. It was also sad because
Moon clearly felt regret for his actions. I mean he should because he did
commit treason, but I feel like many would in his case. He even tells the narrator
to hate him. How sad.
I had the exact same reaction to the beginning of Garden of Forking Paths that I also talked about in my blog! I thought I was going to be SO bored for the entire story, but I actually thought some of the writing and ideas were really really intriguing and cool to think about. I like the quote that you bring up about the past and the present because I also kind of had a mind blown moment when I read that. It really forces you to think about how weird it is that everything happening can only occur in the present - this seems like a simple fact but it is still so strange to consider. I actually liked this story more than The Form of the Sword because of how it forced you to think about such difficult things, like how time can have multiple layers and therefore there are so many different possible outcomes to things. I agree that these confusing ideas distract from the major plot of the story, but I kind of enjoyed that about it.
ReplyDeleteI personally too liked The Form of the Sword more as it presented a more philosophical and mysterious air when reading the story. You do not know who the Englishmen is and also you are presented with ideas of what one man's actions does to the rest of the world. I disagree with you in the fact that a person can not feel regret for their actions after they committed them with full fledged desire to carry it out.
ReplyDeleteI liked the Form of the Sword more as well, and the narrator at the end of the story is a little sad, but he totally just betrayed that awesome guy. That's so totally not cool. The treason part isn't as bad as ratting out someone who saved your life, That is nigh unforgivable.
ReplyDelete